Is obesity animal abuse

By Isabella Storyclaire

last updated September 16, 2024

Contributions sourced from

Animal Cruelty: What You Can Do Right Now to Prevent It

Animal cruelty can often be difficult to recognize but it has proven to be a pervasive problem. No species or community is exempt from the experience of animal abuse and neglect. Understanding what animal cruelty does and does not entail is one of the first steps to helping prevent it from continuing to happen. Animals dont deserve to suffer whether for food, cosmetics, entertainment, or the pet industry.

What Is Animal Cruelty?

Simply put, animal cruelty is causing harm to an animal whether by purposeful action or neglect. Though certain activities are broadly accepted as cruel, such as animal fighting, the specific actions considered animal cruelty vary from individual to individual and from country to country. Many would argue that docking a piglets tail without sedation is cruelty while others would counter that it is standard practice for meat production to prevent injury later on in the pigs life. Laws pertaining to animal cruelty also differ from country to country. Docking a piglets tail as standard procedure is illegal in the European Union (EU) whereas it is common practice in the United States (US).

Who Abuses Animals?

Cruelty to animals is not bound by any particular set of characteristics. Rather, it takes place in every state by every age group and economic class. According to the Humane Society of the United States, men under 30 are more likely to intentionally abuse animals while women over 60 are more likely to participate in animal hoarding.

What Is the Correlation with Domestic Violence?

Animal cruelty has been correlated with domestic violence in what has come to be known as The Link. The Link suggests that people who abuse animals are more likely to also abuse people. One example is that domestic abusers have been known to harm pets as a way of controlling their victims.

Which Species are the Most Common Victims?

The species that are most frequently reported as being the victims of animal cruelty are dogs, cats, horses, and farm animals. Farm animals suffer on factory farms by the thousands, but because they are often exempted from cruelty laws or have much more lax protections than do pets, there is not very much legal action that can be taken to reduce their suffering.

What are the Types of Animal Cruelty?

There are two broadly accepted types of animal cruelty: neglect and intentional.

Credit: Jo-Anne McArthur / We Animals Media

Neglect

Neglect entails providing insufficient care to an animal resulting in harm. A particularly severe example of this is animal hoarding. Animal hoarders are characterized by owning a greater than normal amount of animals, being unable to provide the basic care that the animals require and that they deny that they are unable to provide for the animals.

Intentional

Intentional animal cruelty entails acting to harm an animal. Examples include animal fighting, overworking a horse or other animal, and torture.

How to Recognize Animal Cruelty

Animal cruelty can be difficult to recognize due to the broadness of cruelty and its often private nature. It is also important to recognize that the presence of one or two of the signs below does not necessarily mean that an animal is being abused.

Physical Signs

Physical and behavioral signs of abuse can include:

Flinching at human contact
Unexplained fractures or limping
Extreme submission including urinating, rolling over, and tail tucking
Unprovoked aggression
Whining or whimpering
Wounds that are left untreated
Fur loss

Environmental Signs

Some environmental signs that abuse may be taking place include:

Lack of water or food
Lack of shelter
Constantly being left outside
Dirty environment

Is Animal Cruelty Illegal?

The legality of particular acts of animal cruelty largely depends on where the activity takes place. For example, an act of cruelty against a farm animal or lab animal that would be illegal in some places may not be considered prohibited animal cruelty in some countries due to exceptions in the laws of the individual countries. In the United States, the most prominent law preventing animal cruelty omits both farmed and lab animals from coverage.

Animal Cruelty Laws

The laws pertaining to animal cruelty vary based on the jurisdiction of the activity. Below are a few examples of animal cruelty laws in the United States and the European Union.

United States

The primary federal law about the treatment of animals and the prevention of animal cruelty is the Animal Welfare Act. This law primarily focuses on the housing, care, and transportation of animals used in labs, zoos, and bred and sold commercially. However, several species are not covered under the law: birds, rats, and mice bred for research, and farm animals amongst others. In 2019, the PACT (Preventing Animal Cruelty and Torture) Act was signed into law. The law prohibits the creation and distribution of crush videos, those that involve the crushing and killing of animals. In addition, the law prohibits some of the worst animal cruelty including burning, suffocating, and drowning of animals.

The laws at the federal level can generally only impact those actions that cross state lines. For this reason, most animal cruelty laws in the United States are implemented by states and not the federal government.

Pennsylvania

In Pennsylvania, the term includes failure to provide food, water, necessary veterinary care, and shelter; knowingly overloading, beating, or abandoning; tethering an unattended dog for more than nine hours within a twenty-four-hour window; and animal fighting amongst other acts.

Alabama

In Alabama, cruelty to animals is defined simply as subjecting any animal to mistreatment or cruel neglect. The definition also specifically includes causing harm to an animal belonging to someone else without good reason.

European Union

The EU recognized animals as sentient beings in 2009 adding a requirement that member states pay full regard to the welfare requirements of animals. Before 2009 the EU had the European Convention on the Protection of Animals Kept for Farming Purposes which outlined the expectation that farmed animals be allowed to experience the five freedoms:

Freedom from hunger and thirst
Freedom from discomfort
Freedom from pain, injury, and disease
Freedom to express normal behavior
Freedom from fear and distress

These outlines apply to member states of the EU, but countries also enact their own animal protection laws.

Portugal

Portuguese law dictates a prohibition on unnecessary violence against animals, abandonment, purchasing an injured or sick animal for any purpose other than healing it, among other activities.

Italy

Legislative Decree No. 189/2004 protects animals from three primary areas of cruelty: cruel or unnecessary killing, cruel or unnecessary injury, and abandonment.

Animal Cruelty Felony

All fifty states and the federal government have laws that allow for animal cruelty to be prosecuted as a felony. Felonies are considered the most serious class of crimes in the United States.

Federal

The PACT Act provides for the prosecution of those that perform certain cruel acts such as crushing, burning, or suffocating animals to be tried for a felony.

Florida

In the state of Florida, animal cruelty that results in the death or repeated harm of an animal is considered a third-degree felony. The perpetrator can be charged with up to 5 years in prison and a $10,000 fine.

Idaho

In Idaho, poisoning an animal can be considered a felony punishable by up to 3 years in prison and a $5,000 fine. Causing the death or serious physical injury to working dogs or horses can result in up to 5 years in prison and a $10,000 fine.

How Can We Stop Animal Cruelty?

There are several steps that can be taken to help reduce animal cruelty.

Adopt

Adopting pets instead of purchasing helps to ensure that there is space in animal shelters for pets that may be the victims of cruelty. In addition, it helps by not contributing to the cruelty of puppy mills.

Donate

By donating time, money, and other resources to animal shelters you can help to increase the number of animals that rescues are able to help. Other animal organizations, such as HSUS, SPCA, Mercy for Animals, and Animal Equality can also use donations to help with investigations of animal cruelty.

Teach

Perhaps the most effective method of cutting down cruelty is making sure that the next generation of pet owners, kids, know how to treat animals and provide them with proper care.

Purchase

Looking for cruelty-free products and eating a more plant-based diet helps reduce animal cruelty by limiting the number of animals suffering in labs for the production of cosmetics or on factory farms for food.

How to Report Animal Cruelty

There are several methods by which animal cruelty can be reported depending on the medium.

Report Cruelty Seen on the Internet

To report animal cruelty seen online you can file a report with the Internet Crime Complain Center. You can report to the center whether you live within the US or abroad, as long as the suspected abuser resides within the United States.

Report Cruelty in Movies or on Television

There are two primary resources available for reporting animal cruelty in movies and on television. The first is PETAs whistleblower line that can be reached at 323-210-2233 or emailed at [emailprotected]. The other resource is the American Humane Associations Movie and Television Unit which can be reached at (818) 501-0123.

Reporting Cruelty Witnessed in Person

Animal cruelty can be reported to the local authorities. Within the United States, most communities have an animal-specific arm of law enforcement to whom the local police can direct you. Before contacting the authorities, however, consider reaching out to a local shelter or animal hospital to discuss the situation to see what they suggest are the best next steps.

Understanding Animal Cruelty

Understanding animal cruelty is one of the first steps to stopping it from occurring. By being aware of what is happening in your community, donating your time or other resources, being cognizant of the products you purchase and making sure that the children in your life know proper animal care, you can help stop animal suffering.

The most common form of animal abuse is overfeeding.

Years ago, I read a comment that has stayed with me.

When asked by a local animal control officer to name the most common form of animal abuse that he had ever seen, a veterinarians answer on a message board I read for equine veterinarians was easy, if unexpected: overfeeding.

Thats right. Overfeeding.

So, right about now, I would guess that you are doing one of two things:

Preparing to move to another web site.
Staring at the potato chip you were about to hand to your dog.

Put down the chip, but stay here for a minute. Ill explain.

Ive had this same discussion with horse owners, animal control officers, and the concerned public. It may be counter-intuitive, but in more than a decade of veterinary practice Ive seen far more health issues arise from animal obesity than from emaciation. Most of the underfed animals that Ive seen in recent years - usually horses because I am a large animal vet - have done just fine once they were given some decent groceries. (Some exceptions definitely apply here, particularly for growing or sick animals or those fed bizarrely unbalanced diets.) Obese animals, however, can develop a raft of problems, many of which are irreversible.

The other problem with overfeeding is that the abusers are usually sweet, loving people who have no idea that they are destroying their animals health. Yeah, Im looking at you, holding the bag of Ruffles and the bucket of grain that you were about to take to the barn.

In my experience, conversations regarding feeding the overly voluptuous animal tend to go something like the following.

Veterinarian (hesitantly, and backing slowly away): You know, Muffy looks like shes been putting on some weight. What are you feeding her?

Horse owner (with beaming smile): I know, shes finally filled out. She gets alfalfa twice a day, a bucket of grain, and her bran mash.

Veterinarian (studying Muffy, who has not only filled out, but is filling the barn aisle): I see. I think you may want to start cutting back a bit. Maybe cut the grain, or substitute some grass hay for the alfalfa?

Owner: Oh, but she would be so sad without her grain. And she wont eat grass hay. We offer it free choice, all day, but once she eats the alfalfa she just tramples the grass hay around and lays in it.

(NOTE: Alfalfa is the equine equivalent of chocolate cake or a good steak dinner, and grass hay is analogous to steamed broccoli. If you gave me a chocolate cake or filet mignon twice a day, Id probably nest in the broccoli too.)

Veterinarian: You know, carrying all of this extra weight will make Muffy more likely to develop insulin resistance, arthritis, and laminitis. Shell also grow horns and a second head. (Ok, not the last two.)

Owner (somewhat affronted): Shes never had any problems and I think horses look better when theyre a little conditioned. (Rolls Muffy back into her stall.)

This conversation could be replayed with a dog, cat, or pig owner with the appropriate dietary changes. In developed societies we increasingly love our animals and our food. These twin obsessions have created a monstrous chimera: pet overfeeding. Its bad enough that humans manage to consume more than a full days worth of calories in one lunch, but the existence of weight loss medications for dogs seems to me to be a sign that First World nutrition has gone off the deep end.

Will some animals have a physiologic propensity for being overweight? Sure. Just like humans, some animals have musculoskeletal problems that limit exercise or metabolic issues that prevent them from burning calories normally. Certain breeds tend to be easy keepers. However, just as with humans, a major cause of obesity in animals is the most simple one: the energy equation is unbalanced. Calories in are greater than calories out.

Newsflash: while your pet does not care if she looks good in a bikini, she does care if she can breathe, walk, chase a ball, or run through a pasture. Your pet will not be insulted by being called fat. She will, however, suffer if her joints are forced to carry extra pounds for years.

Sure, your pet likes food treats. Who doesnt? However, just as I can reward myself with a new book instead of a donut or margarita, positive reinforcement for your pet can come from somewhere other than the grocery or feed store.

Ultimately weight management in pets, as in humans, should not be about emotion, status, appearance, or self-worth. It should be about one thing only: health.

Your veterinarian can help you understand and monitor the ideal body condition for your animals. Because, yes, an animal who is being starved is definitely being mistreated, but so is the animal that is fed so well that hes starting to resemble a couch.

Editor's Note: An obese cat had to be rescuedfrom between two fence posts after she got stuck trying to get through. The cat weighed 14.4 pounds.